The Holy Virgin Mary, Chris Ofili and the Brooklyn Controversy

Explains Ofili’s Holy Virgin Mary, its materials and the controversy surrounding his depiction of Mary.

Chris Ofili’s painting of the Virgin Mary combines a Black Madonna with glitter, collage and elephant dung. Made in 1996, the work became the focus of a public dispute when it appeared in the Brooklyn Museum’s 1999 exhibition Sensation. Its materials and imagery prompted objections from religious and political figures; its display also raised a separate question about public funding and government action against a museum.

The painting belongs to the Museum of Modern Art in New York. Its collection record identifies the materials, describes the image and records statements by the artist. Reading that record alongside contemporary accounts and the court decision gives a fuller picture than the controversy alone.

Chris Ofili, The Holy Virgin Mary: materials and image

In The Holy Virgin Mary, Chris Ofili depicts Mary as a Black woman against a luminous, patterned background. The canvas measures approximately 8 feet by 6 feet. MoMA lists acrylic and oil paint, polyester resin, paper collage, glitter, map pins and elephant dung among its materials. The work combines painted and attached elements; the surface is more complex than a reproduction of the central figure alone may suggest.

A piece of dried elephant dung forms the exposed breast of the figure. Two further pieces support the painting at its base. According to MoMA, map pins spell “Virgin” and “Mary” on those supports. These details matter because descriptions that say only that the painting was “covered” in dung do not explain where the material appears or how the work is presented.

Small collaged images surround the figure. MoMA describes them as images of women’s buttocks cut from pornographic magazines and arranged in forms resembling cherubs. Cherubs are familiar figures in Christian religious art, often appearing as winged attendants. Here, their apparent shape and the source of the cutouts create a tension between sacred imagery and sexual imagery that a viewer may notice only on close inspection.

The materials shape both the structure and appearance of the Virgin Mary painting by Ofili. The supports lift the canvas from the floor, while the painted surface, resin and glitter reflect light. A photograph can show the composition, but a viewer also needs the material description to understand how the objects are attached and displayed.

What did Ofili say about the image?

For Chris Ofili, the Holy Virgin Mary was a subject that could be approached through contemporary visual culture. MoMA records his description of the work as a “hip-hop” version and relates that phrase to the use of sampling: combining and transforming elements drawn from existing sources. The museum also quotes him discussing the sexual charge he saw in earlier paintings of the Virgin. These are the artist’s expressed comparisons, not instructions that settle every viewer’s response.

For Chris Ofili, Virgin Mary imagery could draw on both religious painting and the visual language of his own time. The Black figure, the brilliant ground and the small collages invite comparison with traditions of depicting Mary while departing from many familiar European examples. The painting’s title establishes its subject, but it does not require viewers to agree on the meaning of each material or image.

MoMA’s account also notes the use of elephant dung elsewhere in Ofili’s work. That context helps distinguish a recurring artistic material from the idea that it was selected solely for this painting. It does not erase the fact that some viewers objected to its placement in an image of a figure they regard as holy.

The artist’s interpretation and a critic’s response answer different questions. The first can explain what associations Ofili brought to the work. The second can explain why a viewer found the result moving, irreverent or offensive. Neither should be presented as a direct observation of the other’s motives.

From exhibition to public dispute

The Virgin Mary painting by Ofili traveled as part of Sensation: Young British Artists from the Saatchi Collection. After showings in London and Berlin, the exhibition reached the Brooklyn Museum in 1999. The show included works by several artists; the dispute over Ofili’s image became one prominent part of the response to the larger exhibition.

New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani objected to the work and described it as offensive to Catholics. The city moved to withhold funding from the museum. The museum sued, arguing that the threatened action punished it for the content of an exhibition. The sequence is documented in the federal court’s November 1, 1999 decision.

The court granted a preliminary injunction, an interim order issued while litigation was pending. It found that the museum had shown irreparable harm and a likelihood of success on its First Amendment claim, and barred retaliatory action against the museum for displaying the exhibition. That decision addressed government conduct and constitutional rights. It did not decide whether Catholics or other viewers should consider the painting reverent, offensive or artistically successful.

The distinction is important when recounting the dispute. A public official’s objection, a museum’s exhibition decision and a judge’s ruling each have a different status. One expresses a judgment about the work; another involves an institution’s curatorial choice; the third concerns legal limits on government action. Combining them into a single verdict would obscure the issue each participant was addressing.

Religious responses and public language

For Catholics, Mary holds a distinctive place as the mother of Jesus and is honored in prayer, devotion and art. A depiction that combines her image with material associated with excrement and images from pornography can therefore raise serious questions about reverence. That explains the grounds on which some viewers objected without requiring an assumption that every Catholic reacted in the same way.

Contemporary reporting recorded criticism by New York’s Cardinal John O’Connor during the dispute. His response was that of a named church leader in a particular public controversy; Giuliani’s response was that of the mayor. Neither should be presented, without further evidence, as a comprehensive official judgment by the worldwide Catholic Church. Individual Catholics, artists and museum visitors could assess the painting differently.

Accounts of the work can also become misleading when they replace the object with a shorthand. The collaged images were small elements around the figure; the dung was attached at a breast and used for supports. Those facts can be stated plainly without requiring a reader to adopt either the artist’s interpretation or an opponent’s conclusion.

When a claim about the controversy appears in a later account, the useful questions are specific: who made the statement, when, and in what role? Was the speaker discussing the artwork, the use of public money, or a legal remedy? A quotation from a politician is evidence of that politician’s position. A court order is evidence of what the court ordered and the reasons it gave at that stage.

Can the painting be seen today?

MoMA lists the painting in its collection as a gift from Steven and Alexandra Cohen. Its collection page currently identifies the work as not on view. Display schedules can change, so readers planning a visit should check the museum’s listing for its latest status.

Author: Kelly Hall